0
0
Gift cards have become a go-to present for birthdays, holidays, and even “just because” moments. According to a report by Statista, Americans spent over $171 billion on gift cards in 2022 alone. That’s a huge number—and it shows just how popular and convenient they are.
But here’s the catch: many people make mistakes when buying or giving gift cards. These errors can lead to disappointment, unused balances, or worse—lost money. If you’ve ever given a card and later heard it went unused, or worse, expired, you’re not alone.
That’s exactly why this blog exists—to help you avoid the most common gift card blunders. Whether you’re buying for a friend, coworker, or a family member, a thoughtful approach matters. And if you want to explore causes that matter while gifting with meaning, take a moment to explore Bra Day USA for ideas that support breast reconstruction awareness.
Let’s dig in and fix these mistakes before they happen.
1. Choosing the Wrong Store or Brand
Not everyone shops at the same places. A gift card for a trendy clothing store may not suit a senior citizen, just like a tech gadget retailer may not work for someone who prefers handmade items.
Here’s what often goes wrong:
- You pick a store you love instead of one they love.
- You assume they’ll shop online, but they prefer in-store.
- You choose a niche brand, but they like big retailers.
How to fix this mistake:
Do a little homework. Think about where your recipient shops or eats regularly. Ask someone close to them if you’re unsure. If you’re really in doubt, go with a general-use card like Visa or Mastercard—but even then, read the terms.
Once, I gave my uncle a gift card to a high-end steakhouse. Turns out, he’d been vegan for six months. I hadn’t checked. He appreciated the gesture but never used it. Lesson learned: know your audience.
2. Forgetting to Check Expiration Dates and Fees
Many people assume gift cards last forever. That’s not always true. Some come with hidden expiration dates, dormancy fees, or monthly charges that start eating away at the balance.
According to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), gift cards can’t expire for at least five years after activation. However, inactivity fees may apply after just 12 months if there’s no usage.
Common issues include:
- Cards that lose value over time.
- Forgetting the card in a drawer until it’s too late.
- Unused balances that disappear.
Always read the fine print. Choose gift cards that clearly state “no expiration” or have consumer-friendly policies. Encourage your recipient to use the card soon to avoid any issues.
Store digital copies or receipts. If the card gets lost, that proof might help you get it replaced.
3. Buying from Unverified Sellers
Sure, online marketplaces may offer discounted gift cards—but not all of them are safe. Scammers love to prey on unsuspecting shoppers, especially around the holidays.
You risk:
- Getting a fake or empty card.
- Purchasing a stolen card.
- Losing your money with no way to get it back.
Better options:
Only buy gift cards from reputable sources like the brand’s official website, a major retailer, or a verified platform such as Raise or CardCash. Always verify customer reviews and seller ratings.
A friend of mine found a great deal on a $50 card for $30. He bought it—only to find it had a $0 balance. The seller vanished. That “deal” turned into a waste of money.
4. Being Too Generic with the Message
A gift card can feel impersonal if it’s just handed over with no thought or message. Even a $100 card can seem cold if it comes without a personal touch.
Avoid doing this:
- Tossing it in a blank envelope.
- Sending a text with just the code.
- Skipping a personal note.
Try this instead:
Pair the card with a handwritten message. Say why you chose it, or what you hope they enjoy with it. Even better, include a small physical item that matches the theme—like a coffee mug with a Starbucks card.
People don’t remember the amount—they remember the feeling behind it.
5. Ignoring the Recipient’s Tech Comfort Level
Digital gift cards are easy to send, but not everyone is comfortable using them. Elderly recipients might struggle with accessing digital codes, QR scans, or mobile apps.
Consider this:
- Can they print a digital card?
- Do they shop online or prefer stores?
- Would they know how to redeem it?
Solution:
For older adults, go with physical cards and include a note explaining how to use them. Help them register the card if needed.
6. Giving Low-Balance Cards That Limit Use
Giving a $5 gift card might seem like a fun gesture—but it can also be frustrating. Many items cost more than that, forcing the recipient to spend their own money to use the gift.
Problems this causes:
- Makes the gift feel cheap or incomplete.
- Creates a hassle rather than a joy.
- Might lead to the card being forgotten or unused.
What works better:
Stick to round, usable amounts like $10, $25, $50, or $100. Think of what they can actually buy with it.
Group smaller cards together. For example, a “coffee lover’s bundle” of two $10 cards to different cafes can feel thoughtful and fun.
7. Not Registering the Card
Some cards allow you to register them online. This offers added protection if the card is lost or stolen. But many people skip this step.
Why it matters:
- You can check balances.
- You can request a replacement.
- You can track usage.
Action steps:
If you’re giving a reloadable or prepaid Visa/Mastercard, register it online for the recipient or guide them to do so. It only takes a few minutes and can save the card from going to waste.
8. Sending the Card Late or at the Wrong Time
Timing matters. A birthday card that shows up a week late loses its charm. A holiday gift card delivered after Christmas might seem like an afterthought.
Mistakes people make:
- Forgetting to order early.
- Relying on slow delivery options.
- Not considering the recipient’s schedule.
Tips to improve:
- Schedule delivery if using email-based cards.
- Send physical cards 5–7 days in advance.
- Follow up to confirm they received it.
According to National Retail Federation (NRF), nearly 50% of consumers expect to receive digital gift cards within 24 hours of purchase. Don’t leave them waiting.
9. Skipping the Follow-Up
The gift card experience doesn’t end at delivery. Following up can make the gift even more valuable.
Try asking:
- “Did you get a chance to use it?”
- “What did you buy with the card?”
- “Was it easy to redeem?”
These little check-ins show you care. They also give you insights for future gifts.
You might hear about how they used the card—like discovering a new book, trying a meal, or buying something meaningful.
10. Not Keeping the Receipt or Proof of Purchase
Sometimes, cards don’t activate properly. Or they get lost. Without a receipt, you’re stuck.
Mistakes include:
- Throwing away activation slips.
- Not noting down the card number.
- Forgetting to register the card.
What to do instead:
- Take a photo of the front and back of the card.
- Keep the receipt in your email or wallet.
- Ask for a gift receipt if buying in-store.
This 30-second habit can save your entire gift.
Conclusion
Gift cards can be amazing—but only when done right. The key is knowing your recipient, picking wisely, and avoiding common mistakes. Whether you’re buying one card or ten, putting in a little extra thought goes a long way.
So next time you shop for a gift card, ask yourself:
Will this feel thoughtful, usable, and easy for them to enjoy?
That’s the difference between a generic gift—and a great one.
Have any stories about giving or receiving gift cards? Share them in the comments below! And don’t forget to pass this article along to help others avoid these mistakes.
FAQs
What is the safest way to buy gift cards?
Buy directly from the retailer’s website or in-store. Avoid unknown sellers or sketchy third-party websites.
Do gift cards expire?
Some do. Legally, they can’t expire for five years, but inactivity fees may apply sooner. Always check the terms.
How can I make a gift card feel more personal?
Include a note explaining why you chose the card. Add a small themed gift or a creative wrapping.
Can lost gift cards be replaced?
Sometimes. If you registered the card or kept the receipt, contact customer support. They may offer a replacement.
Are digital or physical gift cards better?
It depends on the recipient. Tech-savvy people may prefer digital cards. Others might find physical cards easier to use.
